ebookclassics

Jane Eyre (2006) – Series Review

Books Into Movies Monthly Meme Button 1The following is a review for Hobby Buku’s monthly Books Into Movies meme.

I wasn’t going out of my way to watch another Jane Eyre adaptation. But when you walk into the library and it’s the first thing you see, you think the universe is trying to tell you something.

In this case it was the BBC television series from 2006 starring Ruth Wilson and Toby Stephens. The adaptation was well received by critics as being fairly faithful to the book. It was nominated for and won several BAFTA and Primetime Emmy Awards.

The adaptation

The series is almost 4 hours long and I had to watch it over three viewings (such is life with kids), but it was very satisfying for me as a fan of Jane Eyre. A series is a nice treat because the story isn’t as rushed. I had a chance to understand some things I missed in the book, such as all the talk about twins representing the supernatural love connection between Jane and Rochester. I also liked that the series embellished scenes with the two lovers to emphasize it was the real deal. I have always felt there was not enough romance in the book convince me Jane and Rochester were actually in love.

Physically, Ruth Wilson is not “mousy” as we know our beloved heroine, so I felt she was lacking some vulnerability. However, she’s a very good actress and excellently conveyed all of Jane’s intelligence and strength.

As for Toby Stephens … wow! He brought Mr. Rochester to life for me and made me see what so many have known forever. Mr. Rochester is awesome! I didn’t get it when I read the book and I came around a little when I watched the 2011 movie, but I finally saw through Mr. Stephens’ performance the arrogance and humour masking Rochester’s fear, regret and self-hatred.

Comparison to the book

The series covered the parts of the book that I felt were important with the exception of rushing through Jane’s friendship with Helen Burns (they meet and she dies within 5 minutes) and completely omitting the influence of her teacher, Miss Temple. I felt this way about the 2011 adaptation I watched back in April. But despite these misgivings, I agreed with condensing Jane’s time with the Rivers family and focusing on her relationship with Mr. Rochester.

Of course, I missed Jane’s poetic narration, her witty and intelligent observations. I missed hearing how she was feeling in a moment, especially how she felt about people like Blanche Ingram. As much as the read-the-book-first rule is hard to follow, you wouldn’t appreciate watching the story without having read the book.

Comparison to the 2011 movie

In my April review, I concluded that the movie starring Mia Wasikowska and Michael Fassbender was not a great adaptation of Jane Eyre. Comparing the movie to this BBC series, I can definitely say the series does a better job telling Jane’s story. The movie is entertaining and the actors competent, but I realize now how much of the story was missing. However, both adaptations do not shortchange you on romantic scenes (or bare chests).

Conclusion

The BBC version of Jane Eyre is really good! I recommend it over the 2011 movie (sorry Michael Fassbender) as it is very loyal to the book. It will definitely please any fan.

The read-the-book-first rule is hard to follow because it’s clear I understand the story better when I can see the action unfold. I feel like I can appreciate Jane Eyre even more now that I have two adaptations under my belt. I could possibly become an Eyreaholic … who would’ve thunk?

Advertisements

4 comments on “Jane Eyre (2006) – Series Review

  1. Hobby Buku
    July 25, 2013

    OMG !! I love this version rather than big screen movie adaptation. And I really think Toby Stephen plays the character very well indeed 😀 and lots of classic movie adaptation I like are from BBC version, ‘coz they not changing too much or even cutting the whole scene just for popular demand (like almost Hollywood adaptation)
    Now I really want re-watching again >,<
    (might be next month while I re-read this book again :D)

    Like

    • ebookclassics
      July 30, 2013

      Do it! You may have a different perspective about certain things in the book after seeing this adaptation. I really loved this version too. It was so satisfying as a fan of the book.

      Like

  2. Jorie
    September 3, 2013

    I glossed over this, as I haven’t yet seen this adaptation, but what I wanted to say is that I was celebrating with a smile when I saw that you are now an Eyre champion! 🙂 🙂 Hmm,… you know, its not too late to join Septemb-Eyre if you still want to read the book!!? I’m reading it for the first time myself!? Here’s my post on Septemb-Eyre if your keen to give it a go! I provide the links you need to sign-up but also to see the specifics of what it includes! As well as a running list of everyone participating as I am making my way around to the Septemb-Eyre girls’ blogs tonight! We have not yet found a bloke to join us! 🙂

    Ooh, what I was going to say is that I *love!* seeking out ALL adaptations of books/films!! I could speak for hours about how I have followed “Little Women” and “An Affair to Remember” throughout motion picture history! Each new edition always brings me closer to the story and characters, as much as seeing the different interpretations! Ooh, “The Little Princess” and “The Secret Garden” came to mind,…

    Like

    • ebookclassics
      September 4, 2013

      I read Jane Eyre back in January and I think I missed a lot of important things in the book, so I will definitely need to read it again one day. I have seen two Little Women adaptations, but never read the book or An Affair to Remember or any of the other books you mention. I’m a little bit behind all of the classics. I’m trying to catch up now!

      Like

Thoughts? Comments?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Information

This entry was posted on June 11, 2013 by in Headlines and tagged , .

Now reading

and …

and …

%d bloggers like this: